LOST (Spoilers!)

I agree. I'm 90% sure that in the first season the purgatory or limbo was the Island (that's why they put Christian character's on it, i'm sure the original version of his speech was planned to be on the island ) . but people figure out too soon and they changed the plan.

The problem is that it all ends up too BROADLY, with typical WIDE themes imported from Christianity, spirituality and so on. "Big white light solves everything"-type logic. That's simply not justified by all the SPECIFIC going-ons of the preceding 6 seasons. So the problem was planted long ago. They would have needed to weed out a lot of stuff, either making the show shorter or by dwelling more on certain plot points that they KNEW they could resolve at the end.

I agree, but I think that "Big white light" theme of the last three episodes could be very easily digested (meaning: I totally buy what they're trying to do, emphasising the larger themes and the character relationships in the ending), had they only not dismissed some of the smaller - more unimportant in the larger framework - mysteries and loose ends, which they clearly DID have answers for, and do not fall under the category "you can ask another question for each answer".
But they ignored that in the end, in their discourse and in the series, miscalculating the balance of mystery show and character study that the series had had from day one. It wasn't as bad as saying in the end that the Rambaldi mythology didn't mean anything, but was just meant as a plot device for boring (and meaningless!) spy antics of Jennifer Garner in Alias, but it goes in the same direction.
Addressing more of the dangling ends of the mythology (Egyptians, Walt, the appearances, the Rules, the ash) and the plot (outrigger, the glass eye, the bear cave corpses, the eye in the Cabin, the volcano, the wheel) would have put the criticism down, and would have put everyone's minds more to that what was 'really' important in the series and what was in the finale.

I was also waiting for Aaron to have this kind of BIG purpose (the new Saviour or whatever), but in the end, he was just a.....baby.

ah yeah, true

Fucking bitch. Someone should have killed her in season 1.

why?

[spoiler]their death[/spoiler] at the end of season 6 is one of the few moving scenes in the entire season

I didn't, alongside the relationship between Penny and Desmond, and Daniel and Charlotte, the most moving chemistry in couples on the island

I would like to add Hurley and Libby to that, but it barely received the time to grow

You can't hate Sun, Sun = life. Without it you perish.

we get it

for me lost was annoying overall after a while, but I did find comfort in those moments when we actually saw good emotional chemistry on screen (supported through of course Giacchino's music)

Oh Locke off... Lost is over !

I'm happy I gave up mid S2.

Your loss.

I don't blame Gilles, I have no intention of watching this overrated tosh ever again. I got as far as S3 and I wish I'd never bothered.

No mate... seeing I already lost interest during one of the more normal seasons (according to my bro) it most definitely doesn't feel like it.

Now Entourage, that one can run until infinity for me. Great great show and it doesn't get ridiculous, as far as my knowledge on the movie business goes anyway.

Ignorance is bliss after all.